The clock strikes twelve, you swallow the last of the twelve grapes we eat at midnight here in Spain and, between hugs, the list is already in your head. This year, definitely. You'll join the gym, eat better, read more and keep your phone out of the bedroom. On 2 January you start full of energy. By mid-February the gym bag is back at the bottom of the wardrobe and you're telling yourself you have no willpower. If this happens to you every year, you're not a lost cause. It very often happens with New Year's resolutions, and psychology has spent decades studying why.
In this article I explain why we make New Year's resolutions, how many are really kept, why so many fail and what research says about making them last.
Why we make New Year's resolutions
A new year feels like a blank page. Three researchers called this the 'fresh start effect'. They found that Google searches for the word 'diet', gym visits and commitments to pursue goals all increase right after dates that feel like a turning point, such as the start of a new week, month, year or semester, a birthday or a holiday (Dai and colleagues, 2014).
According to the authors, these dates help us leave our imperfections in an earlier period and take a wider view of our lives, which encourages us to try to change. 1 January is probably the most powerful of them all, but it isn't the only one. Further down you'll see why that's good news.
How many New Year's resolutions are kept?
People often say that hardly anyone keeps their New Year's resolutions. The data are less gloomy.
In the late 1980s, a two-year study followed 200 people who had made New Year's resolutions. After one week, 77% were keeping them. After two years, 19% were (Norcross and Vangarelli, 1988-1989).
More than a decade later, another study by the same researcher compared 159 people who had made a New Year's resolution with 123 who wanted to change something later on but hadn't set themselves a resolution. Six months later, 46% of the first group said they were still keeping it. In the second group, only 4% said they had managed the change (Norcross and colleagues, 2002). The groups weren't formed at random, so the study doesn't prove that making a resolution is the cause, but the gap is very wide.
More recently, an experiment carried out in Sweden with 1,066 people found that, one year on, 55% of the participants who responded felt they had kept their resolutions (Oscarsson and colleagues, 2020). They were volunteers and almost a third didn't respond at the one-year mark, so the real figure may be lower.
The most common New Year's resolutions
In that Swedish experiment, people were free to word their own resolutions. Going by the first one each participant wrote down, this is how they were split:
- Physical health, 33%.
- Losing weight, 20%.
- Changing eating habits, 13%.
- Personal growth, 9%.
- Mental health and sleep, 5%.
- The remaining 20% were about work, studies or smoking, among other things.
So two out of three were about the body. Your list may look quite similar.
Why New Year's resolutions fail
When New Year's resolutions are dropped, in my experience there are usually more specific reasons than laziness. These are some of the ones that research and clinical practice point to.
Unrealistic expectations
Polivy and Herman (2002) call it the 'false hope syndrome'. We expect to change faster, by a greater amount and with less effort than is realistic, and we trust that the change will fix our lives more than it actually will. When reality falls short, we give up, and some time later we try again with the same expectations.
Too many resolutions, and too vague
'Get fit', 'be more organised', 'look after myself'. These are wishes, but they don't tell you what you'll be doing on Monday at seven in the evening. And if there are ten on the list, they all compete for the same time and energy. The photo in this article is a good example, with fifteen resolutions on a single page.
Resolutions worded as a negative
'Stop eating sweets', 'not look at my phone so much'. In the Swedish experiment, people with approach-oriented goals, meaning goals about starting to do something, rated themselves as more successful than those who set out to avoid or give up something (58.9% compared with 47.1%). This is an association, not proof that the wording is the cause.
All-or-nothing thinking
One day you skip a workout or finish off the leftover Christmas sweets, and you conclude that you've ruined everything. This is all-or-nothing thinking, one of the cognitive distortions. But a slip doesn't mean you've failed. In the Norcross and Vangarelli study, 53% of those who kept their resolution had slipped at least once, and the average was 14 slips over the two years. Slips tended to come at times of low personal control, excessive stress and negative emotion.
Relying on willpower alone
Willpower matters, but it doesn't work alone. In that same study, the people who succeeded said they had made more use than the rest of stimulus control (arranging your surroundings so that they help), reinforcement (rewarding your own progress) and willpower.
A habit takes longer than you think
You often hear that it takes 21 days to form a habit. A review of 20 studies with 2,601 participants gives higher figures. In the four studies that measured it, the median times for a health habit to become automatic were between 59 and 66 days, the means ranged from 106 to 154 days and, depending on the person, it took anywhere from 4 to 335 days (Singh and colleagues, 2024). In mid-February, when many of us run out of steam, the habit is still forming.
How to keep your New Year's resolutions
These strategies for keeping New Year's resolutions are backed by research.
Choose one or two New Year's resolutions
One change that lasts until summer is worth more than ten that don't make it past the first week of January. Pick the one that matters most to you and leave the rest for later.
Word them as something to do, and be specific
Turn 'stop' into 'start'. Instead of 'spend fewer hours on the sofa', try 'walk for half an hour on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays after lunch'.
One caveat. In the Swedish experiment, the group with the most support was also taught to set specific, time-framed goals with interim targets, and it was no more successful than the control group. The authors suggest that a very specific goal also makes it clearer when you aren't meeting it. Being specific helps you know what you have to do. Judge the resolution by how the month is going, not by each day.
Plan for obstacles
Picture what you want to achieve, think about the most likely obstacle and prepare a response along the lines of 'if this happens, then I'll do that'. For example, 'if I leave work late, then I'll do twenty minutes on the exercise bike at home'. This technique is called mental contrasting with implementation intentions. A meta-analysis of 21 studies with 15,907 participants found it had a small to medium effect on achieving goals, although the authors warn that the real effect may be smaller (Wang and colleagues, 2021).
Tell someone
The Swedish experiment had three groups, and the one with the best results was the group that received some support. Participants read information about the value of other people's support, named a person to back them up through the year, completed a follow-up questionnaire every month and were sent an email with exercises. The difference was small, and the third group, which received all of that plus more material, did not beat the control group, so it isn't clear which part helped. A meta-analysis of 141 papers found that setting goals worked better when the goal was made public or shared by a group (Epton and colleagues, 2017). Tell someone what you want to do and ask them to check in on how it's going.
Keep track of how you're doing
A review of 138 studies with close to 20,000 participants concluded that monitoring your progress helps you reach your goals, and even more so when you write it down and share it with someone (Harkin and colleagues, 2016). A calendar on the fridge where you tick off the days will do.
Make it easy at home
Leave your trainers by the door and the fruit where you can see it. Turn off notifications for the apps that steal your nights and charge your phone outside the bedroom. The less it depends on deciding every single day, the better.
Expect slips
They're likely. More than half of the people who succeed have at least one. When the first one comes, look at what happened and carry on the next day. Being harsh with yourself doesn't usually help. In an analysis of 15 samples with 3,252 people, those who treated themselves with more self-compassion were also the ones who practised more health behaviours, such as eating well, exercising, sleeping and managing stress (Sirois and colleagues, 2015). It's a modest association, and it doesn't prove cause.
Examples of well-worded New Year's resolutions
- Instead of 'do more exercise', 'go swimming on Tuesdays and Thursdays straight after work'.
- Instead of 'eat better', 'take a packed lunch from home four days a week'.
- Instead of 'use my phone less', 'read for a quarter of an hour in bed while my phone charges in the living room'.
- Instead of 'save money', 'move 50 euros to another account on payday'.
- Instead of 'be less stressed', 'keep Sunday afternoons free of plans and screens'.
- Instead of 'look after my mental health', 'book an appointment with a psychologist before the end of January'.
When New Year's resolutions do more harm than good
Some resolutions come from wanting to look after yourself, and others come from rejecting yourself. 'Lose weight because I can't stand myself' is not the same as 'move more because I feel better when I do'. Resolutions born of self-rejection usually come with self-criticism, comparisons on social media and guilt every time you fall short.
If you lean towards perfectionism, a list of resolutions can become one more yardstick to measure yourself against. And if your self-esteem depends on keeping them, every slip weighs twice as much.
Be careful, too, with weight and diet resolutions if you've had a difficult relationship with food. In that case, talk to a professional before starting any restrictive diet.
What if you've already given up on your resolution?
There's no need to wait for another New Year. The fresh start effect has also been observed after a Monday, the first of the month or a birthday. Before you try again, ask yourself three questions:
- What happened just before you stopped? Often there's stress, tiredness or a bad week.
- Was it too big? To get going again, my advice is to shrink it until it feels almost too easy.
- Do you want it yourself, or is it what you think you ought to want? The Singh review suggests that habits people choose for themselves tend to take root better.
If what holds you back is that you keep putting it off until tomorrow, the article on procrastination may help.
New Year's resolutions and mental health: when to seek help
In the Swedish experiment, one in twenty participants put mental health or sleep as their first resolution. If yours is one of those, 'feel better' is hard to turn into a plan, and that's where therapy can help.
It's also worth seeing a professional if you repeat the same list with the same guilt every year, or if behind what you want to change there's anxiety, low mood, binge eating, or drinking or drug use you can't control. In those cases it takes more than willpower.
Online therapy and therapy in Igualada to start the year
If one of your New Year's resolutions is to look after your mental health, I can help. I offer online therapy and in-person sessions in Igualada, in Catalan or Spanish. We work with specific goals that can be reviewed, designed for you and not for an ideal list.
Get in touch for a no-obligation first conversation, and we'll look at what you need and how I can help.